I bought my first quart of Absorbine ShowSheen in the late nineties because a woman in the barn aisle at a Scottsdale open show told me it was the only thing that would get burrs out of a tail without pulling half the hair out along with them. She was mostly right, and I have kept a bottle on the shelf ever since. What she did not tell me, and what nobody tells you, is that ShowSheen is a polish first and a detangler second. Use it like a conditioner and you will spend the next twenty years wondering why your mare's tail looks heavy and dull by August. This is the review I wish someone had handed me in that barn aisle.
Here is the short version. ShowSheen does two jobs extremely well. It gets knots and burrs out of fine hair with almost no pulling, and it puts a shine on a coat or a mane that photographs beautifully. It does not repair anything, it does not replace a conditioner, and in Arizona it attracts dust like a porch screen. Whether it deserves shelf space in your barn depends entirely on which of those sentences bothers you most.
The Quick Verdict
The best burr and knot remover I have used on fine hair, provided you treat it as a polish you wash out, not a conditioner you leave in.
Amazon Check Today's Price →Twenty-five years of replacing the same bottle is its own kind of review
Absorbine ShowSheen, quart spray bottle, unscented. The bottle I reach for when a tail is matted and the farrier is due in an hour.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →How I've Used It
I keep three Arabians on twelve acres outside Scottsdale. Sahir is a fourteen-year-old gray gelding and my riding horse. Nadia is a nine-year-old bay mare with thin skin and a low opinion of harsh brushes. Kasim is a twenty-two-year-old chestnut gelding, retired, and mostly grows hair. Three horses is a small sample, but it is three different coats and three different hair types, and I have had them long enough to know what normal looks like on each one.
I used the quart bottle across a full show season and through two monsoon summers. That matters more than a single application, because most of what you learn about a grooming product shows up three weeks in, not on day one. A tail that looks good the morning you spray it and greasy by the following weekend has not solved anything. It has just moved the problem.
The test was simple. Nadia's tail got ShowSheen and nothing else for the whole season. Sahir's mane got ShowSheen before shows and plain water and a curry the rest of the time. Kasim's tail got nothing at all, because he is twenty-two and does not care, and I wanted something to compare against. That untreated tail turned out to be the most useful part of the whole exercise, and I did not expect that going in.
One note on method before anything else. A little goes a long way and it is easy to use twice as much as you need. I made that mistake for years. The tail does not get twice as slick, it just gets tacky a week sooner, and then you are standing in the aisle wondering why the product stopped working when the product never changed.
What Nobody Tells You First: It Is a Polish, Not a Conditioner
The Absorbine label calls it a hair polish and detangler, and that order is honest. What it does is coat each strand. The manufacturer describes that coating as reducing hair breakage by 40%, and I believe the mechanism even if I cannot verify the number from my own barn. A coated strand slides past the strand beside it. That is why a knot lets go.
But a coating is not a repair. If your mare's tail is thin because she rubbed it out on a fence in June, ShowSheen will not grow it back. It will make the hair that is left look better and tangle less, and it will keep you from snapping off what remains, which is worth something real. It just will not touch the reason the hair is gone. I spent a couple of years expecting otherwise and I would like those years back.
There is a second half to this that nobody mentions. Because it coats rather than absorbs, it sits on top. Reapply every few days without washing and you are coating a coating. That is where the dull, tacky, heavy look comes from. It is not the product failing. It is the product being asked to do a job it was never sold to do.
The Desert Dust Problem
In Maricopa County we get dust. Not the romantic kind. Fine pale powder that lifts off a dry lot in a breeze and settles on everything, plus two months of monsoon wind that puts half the county's topsoil into your horse's mane. A freshly polished horse is a dust magnet. Whatever makes the hair slick and shiny will hold onto that powder, and by the end of a trail ride your gray gelding looks like he has been rolling in a driveway.
That is not a defect in the product so much as a mismatch between the product and the place. I stopped putting ShowSheen on Sahir before a dusty ride years ago. Now it goes on the night before a show, when he is stalled and the air is still. If you live somewhere humid and green, none of this will apply to you. If you live here, it is the most important paragraph in this review.
Where It Genuinely Earns Its Place
Burrs. That is the whole case, and it is a strong one. Nadia finds burdock every September along the fence line, and those burrs go into a fine Arabian tail like they were hired to do it. With ShowSheen worked in first, they slide out with fingers. Without it I am picking them apart for forty minutes and losing hair the entire time, and she is getting soured on the whole business.
Wind knots are the second thing. A mane blown into a rat's nest overnight will comb out in two passes instead of twenty. On a thin-skinned mare who has opinions about brushes, twenty passes is not a neutral event. It is a fight that ends with both of us annoyed and her less willing to stand still the next time I walk up with a comb.
The third is the shine, which I am not too proud to say I care about. Sahir is gray, which means every grass stain and every dried sweat mark shows. The label lists horses, cattle, dogs, llamas, pigs, camels, goats, alpacas and sheep, and I have used it on exactly one of those species, but I can tell you that a gray horse after a ShowSheen rubdown looks like a gray horse that has been kept under a roof and fed by hand. At a regional open show that is worth something to me.
The untreated tail on my retired gelding was the most useful part of the test. Three weeks in it was visibly harder to comb than either treated tail, and it stayed that way all summer.
What I Tried Instead
I have worked through the cheaper detanglers, the leave-in conditioners, and the homemade spray a woman at the feed store swore by. The leave-in conditioners do more for the hair itself and less for the tangle, and they leave a softness that a fine Arabian mane genuinely does not need. The inexpensive detanglers work about eighty percent as well and smell like a candle shop. The homemade spray worked fine until it separated in the heat and had to be shaken every thirty seconds.
None of them were bad. ShowSheen is simply the one where I know exactly what I am getting before I pick it up, and the one bottle I have replaced more times than any other grooming product in the barn. That is a boring recommendation and it is the honest one.
The Small Frictions
It is unscented, which I like and which matters on a mare who sneezes at anything perfumed. What it is not is silent. A spray over a sensitive horse is a noise, and Nadia took about a month to decide the hiss was not a predator. I spray it into my hand or onto a brush and work it in from there now. Slower, quieter, and less of it ends up in the air she is breathing.
It is slippery. A tail with fresh product in it will slide out of a braid, and a band that has always held will let go overnight. Do not put it in a mane the morning of a show where the braids have to stay put. I also keep it well away from the saddle patch, the girth area, and anything I have to hold onto. A slicked horse is a horse you get off of in an unexpected way.
The bottle is a quart, ten inches tall, and that is a good size for a barn shelf. It lasts me most of a season across three horses. It is a bad size for a show kit, so I decant some into a smaller sprayer that lives in the trailer and leave the quart at home where it belongs.
What I Liked
- Gets burrs and wind knots out of fine hair with almost no pulling
- Leaves a real show-ring shine on a gray coat, which is not nothing
- Unscented, so it does not set off a sensitive mare
- Coats each strand, and the manufacturer's claim of 40% less breakage matches how the hair behaves in my barn
- The quart lasts most of a season on three horses
- Labeled for horses, cattle, dogs, goats and several other species, useful if you keep more than horses
Where It Falls Short
- It is a polish, not a conditioner, and does nothing for a thin or damaged tail
- Dust and desert grit stick to a freshly polished coat
- Buildup if you keep reapplying without washing it out
- Makes manes slippery enough that braids and bands will not hold
- The spray hiss spooks some horses until they are used to it
How I Use It Now
I gave up spraying it directly onto a horse years ago. It goes into my palm or onto a body brush first, then through the tail from the bottom up, a few inches at a time, working the knots apart with my fingers as I go. Slower, uses less, and keeps the mist out of the air where the horse is standing.
On Sahir I apply it the night before a show, curry it in, and put him in his stall. It settles overnight and the dust has nowhere to land. Show morning he gets a wipe with a clean cloth and nothing else, and he looks better for it than he ever did when I was spraying him an hour before we loaded.
On Nadia's tail it goes on once a week through fly season and after every burr encounter, and it gets washed out on the first of the month whether it looks like it needs it or not. That schedule is the entire difference between the product working and the product being the reason her tail looks bad in July.
Who This Is For
This is for the person with a fine-haired horse, a burr problem, and a show or two a year where the coat matters. It is for anyone who has spent forty minutes on a matted tail and lost hair doing it. Breed is not really the point. Hair type is. The finer and more tangle-prone the mane, the more this earns its place on your shelf.
It is also for the person who wants one bottle that does a visible job. ShowSheen is not subtle. You spray, you comb, the knot is gone, the hair shines. If you like a product that announces its results rather than asking you to be patient for six weeks, this is that product.
Who Should Skip It
Skip it if your horse lives out in blowing dust and you want something you can put on right before a ride. It will collect grit, and you will spend more time currying afterward than you saved by spraying in the first place.
Skip it if what you actually have is a damaged tail that needs conditioning. This is not that. It will mask the problem for a few weeks and then stop masking it, and you will have lost the time. And skip it if your horse reacts to grooming products in general. Unscented is not the same as hypoallergenic, and I would patch test anything on a horse with a history of skin trouble.
The last group is anyone who shows where the mane has to stay braided or banded. Some of us can live with re-banding on show morning. If you cannot, keep this off the mane entirely and use it on the tail and the body only.
The Verdict, Plainly
ShowSheen is the best burr and knot remover I have used on fine hair, and it is not a conditioner, and those two facts are the whole review. If your problem is tangles and shine, this solves it and keeps solving it. If your problem is a thin tail that needs to get thicker, this does not touch it, and no bottle will.
After twenty-five years I still buy it. I buy it knowing I will wash it out monthly, that I will not put it on before a dusty ride, and that I will not put it anywhere near a braid I need to hold. Those are small prices for a tail that combs out in two passes instead of twenty, and for a gray gelding who looks like he was kept under a roof.
One bottle, one job, done properly
If your problem is tangles and shine on fine hair, this is the quart I have replaced more times than any other grooming product in my barn.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →