Short answer first, since that is what I want when I read one of these: for a mane or tail that genuinely tangles, Absorbine ShowSheen is the bottle I reach for. For a horse whose hair is already in decent shape and just needs a clean, finished shine before a show, Vetrolin Shine does that job well and I keep a bottle of it on the tack trunk. Both of them come out of the same company, Absorbine, so this is not a contest between good and bad. It is a question of what you are asking the bottle to do on a Tuesday morning in the dust.

I keep three Arabians on twelve acres outside Scottsdale and I do all the grooming myself. Sahir is a fourteen-year-old gray gelding who can find mud in a drought and wears every speck of it on that coat. Nadia is a nine-year-old bay mare with thin skin and a fine mane that knots the moment wind gets under it. Kasim is twenty-two, retired, and mostly needs his tail kept out of the burrs. Monsoon grit, hard water and a sun that bleaches manes orange by July are the conditions these products get judged under here, not the conditions in a climate-controlled show barn.

Absorbine ShowSheenVetrolin Shine
Tangled tail hairCuts through wind knots in two or three passes; Absorbine coats each strand and puts the breakage reduction at 40 percentHandles light tangles fine; on a genuinely matted tail I still finish the job with ShowSheen
Finish in the ringHigh gloss, close to a wet lookSofter, more natural sheen
Residue under a saddle padSlick if you over-apply, and it wants a real bath eventuallyLighter on the hair and less slick where the pad sits
ScentUnscented, exactly as the label saysNoticeable fragrance that hangs around the horse
Dust and gritSheds desert dust for days between bathsDust settles back into the hair sooner in my experience
Fine, thin manesEasy to overdo; a fine mane can go flat and clumpedEasier to apply with a light hand
Light coats that show every markThe slick surface lets mud rinse off with the hose instead of a scrub brushCosmetic shine, less help with stains
Bottle in hand at the wash rack32 fl oz quart spray bottle, works one-handed while you hold the tailLighter bottle, but I go through it faster, so a season takes more of it
Other animals on the placeLabeled for horses, cattle, dogs, goats, sheep, llamas, alpacas, pigs and camelsI have only ever used it on horses
Best forTangled manes and tails, dust, light-colored coats, one bottle for the whole farmA finished, natural look and a scented, lighter touch

How I Compared Them

I did not run a lab trial, and I am suspicious of anyone who claims to have run one on a single horse. What I did was split Sahir's tail down the middle for two weeks. Left half got ShowSheen, right half got Vetrolin Shine, same wash schedule, same comb, same paddock, same weather. Every morning I combed both halves out and counted the passes before the comb ran free.

I tracked five things: passes to comb through, hair left in the comb, how the tail felt in my hand, how much dust had settled back in by the third day, and whether the hair under the saddle pad felt slick. Then I repeated the whole thing on Nadia's mane, which is finer and much less forgiving of a heavy hand.

Before I got organized about it, I tried the things people tell you to try. I washed both tails with the same shampoo and combed them out wet, which is the single worst thing I have done to a tail and I knew better when I did it. I tried warm water and a wide-tooth comb on its own, which works until it does not, and then you are standing at the wash rack at seven in the morning with a horse leaning on you and a knot that will not move. I tried a soft brush, which polished the outside of the tail and left the actual tangles underneath where they started. None of that was wasted exactly. It just moved the problem around. So when I set up the split I made one rule for myself: the comb starts at the bottom, I count every pass on both halves, and I do not reach for either bottle until the count is written down.

Two weeks is not a season. Hair grows slowly enough that neither bottle can prove much in that stretch, and I will not pretend otherwise. What a two-week split does show you is how each one behaves day to day, and that is the part that decides whether a bottle stays on my tack trunk or gets pushed to the back of the shelf behind the wound cream.

A person's hands spraying a bottle onto a horse's tail at a wash rack

Where ShowSheen Wins

Detangling, plain and simple. ShowSheen coats each strand, and the Absorbine label puts the reduction in hair breakage at 40 percent. I cannot verify 40 percent with a comb and a notebook, but I can tell you that Sahir's tail came free in two or three passes on the ShowSheen side and took noticeably more work on the other, and there was less hair in the comb afterward. On a horse with a thin mane, hair in the comb is the whole argument.

It also holds up to dust better than anything else I have used. My place is dry nine months out of the year, and a tail treated with ShowSheen sheds grit for several days before it starts grabbing dirt again. On a gray that is worth real money, because a slick surface means mud rinses off with the hose instead of a scrub brush and a lot of apologizing. The 32 fl oz quart spray bottle is easy to work one-handed at the wash rack, and the label covers dogs, cattle, goats, sheep, llamas, alpacas, pigs and camels, so a single bottle handles everything on the property.

Here is the day that settled it for me. Second week of July, a monsoon gust came through in the afternoon and dropped about ten minutes of fat rain on ground that had been dry since May, which is the recipe for the worst mud of the year. Sahir went out and rolled in it. Both sides, ears to tail, and he looked pleased with himself. I brought him in expecting half an hour with a curry and a bucket. I hosed him instead. The mud sheeted off his barrel and hindquarters in one pass of the hose and never really set up in the hair. I have hosed a great deal of mud off that horse in fourteen years and it has never come off like that. The tail took a little more work, but the body was a five-minute job and back out he went.

The 40 percent breakage figure on the Absorbine label is not what sold me. What sold me is how much less hair is left in my comb after I do Sahir's tail.

Where Vetrolin Shine Wins

Finish and scent. ShowSheen is unscented, and Vetrolin Shine carries a fragrance that stays with the horse for the day. If you are walking into a show ring and you want the whole picture to feel finished, that counts for something. The shine it leaves is softer too, less of a wet look. On a fine-boned Arabian in an open show, heavy gloss can read as artificial. Vetrolin reads more like a horse that has been fed well and brushed, which is the look I actually want.

It is also lighter on the hair. I could put it on Nadia's mane without the hair going flat or clumping, and the area under her saddle pad did not feel slick the way it does when I am careless with ShowSheen. If your horse already has decent hair and your real problem is polish rather than knots, Vetrolin is the easier bottle to live with day to day.

The finish argument is easiest to see on a show day. I took Nadia to a regional open show last fall and the night before, I put Vetrolin Shine on her mane and worked it through with my fingers, no comb. Under the barn lights it looked like nothing had happened, which is the point. The next morning at the ring the mane lay flat and soft and her bay coat had a sheen to it without any wet look at the ends. A woman stalled next to me asked what I used, because her mare's mane looked sprayed. That is the difference in one sentence. ShowSheen announces itself. Vetrolin Shine does not.

A horse's tail being combed through with a wide-tooth comb in a barn aisle

How the Desert Changes the Answer

Where I live, dust decides more than shine does. A product that leaves hair slick enough to shed grit is doing real work between baths, and that is ShowSheen's strength. In July and August, when the monsoon rolls through and drops a layer of fine silt on everything that stands still, a treated tail comes back to looking decent a full day sooner than an untreated one.

But the desert also bleaches. Manes go orange, tails thin out at the ends, and heavy product on sun-stressed hair can leave it stiff and dull. That is exactly where I want the lighter option, and it is why I do not put ShowSheen on every horse every week. Kasim, at twenty-two, gets the gentler hand and the softer finish, because his tail is the thinnest one on the place.

Hard water is the other thing nobody warns you about out here. Our well water runs hard enough that a tail washed and left alone dries stiff, and any product has to fight that on top of the dust. I noticed the difference on day three rather than day one. The ShowSheen side still moved like hair. The other side was starting to feel a little like straw at the ends by the end of the week. Then there is the sun. By late July the end of Sahir's tail goes from gray to a dull rust color no matter what I put on it, and heavy product on hair that has already been cooked tends to go stiff and dark. That is why I treat tails more lightly in August than I do in March.

If a tangled tail is the real problem, this is the bottle that ends it

Absorbine ShowSheen, 32 fl oz quart spray bottle. Two or three passes on a wind-knotted tail, less hair left in the comb, and a coat that lets go of desert dust for days at a stretch.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

A Note on Using Both

Nothing says you have to pick a side. Mine sit side by side on the tack trunk and most weeks I use both. ShowSheen goes on tails, and on any horse headed out to pasture where dust is a fact of life rather than a problem to solve. Vetrolin goes on manes and on the day before a show, when I want the finish to read as natural instead of sprayed.

The one thing I would not do is layer them on the same patch of hair in the same morning. Two coats of anything and the hair starts to feel heavy, and a heavy tail on an Arabian collects more dirt, not less. Pick one product per body part per day and stop there. That single habit has saved me more grooming time than any bottle has.

Both bottles live in the tack room, out of the sun, because a spray bottle that has sat in a hundred and ten degrees all afternoon is not something I want going onto a horse's hair. On amount: Sahir's tail takes about six pumps worked in from the ends upward, and any more than that is product going on the ground. Nadia's mane takes three, and those go onto my hands first rather than straight onto the hair, because a direct spray on a fine mane puts it all in one spot and you can see exactly where.

Who Should Buy Which

Buy ShowSheen if your problem is tangles, dust, or a light-colored coat that shows every mark. If you have ever stood in a wash rack working a knot out of a tail while the horse danced around you, this is the bottle that ends that particular fight. It is also the one to buy if you keep other animals, because the Absorbine label covers most of a small farm and one quart does the work of three products.

Buy Vetrolin Shine if your horse's hair is already in good shape and you want a finished look without the wet gloss, or if you want a scent and a lighter hand on a fine mane. If you show and you care how the coat reads under a judge's eye, it is the more polished of the two. If you only ever buy one bottle, buy the ShowSheen, because it solves a problem instead of improving a good situation.

The horse that made me keep both bottles is Kasim. He is twenty-two, he is retired, and his tail is the thinnest one out there. He does not need gloss. He needs the burrs out of it once a week without another inch coming out in the comb, and ShowSheen does that with the least handling. If you have an older horse with a thin tail, that is the whole case for the quart right there. If you keep goats or a dog on the same place, the same bottle covers them too, which is not nothing on twelve acres.

Solve the tangle first, then worry about the polish

For most Arabian owners the order is ShowSheen for manes and tails, Vetrolin Shine later for show-day finish. In my barn a quart of ShowSheen gets through most of a show season on three horses.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →