I bought the first bottle of Cowboy Magic Yellowout because of a photograph I took of my own horse. Sahir is a 14-year-old gray Arabian gelding, and by late March his coat had gone the color of dirty dishwater along the barrel and over the hips. Desert dust, irrigated pasture grass, and a winter of blankets rubbing the wrong way had done it. I had a regional open show six weeks out and a gray horse who looked like he had been rolled in a puddle and left to dry. Anybody who has owned a gray knows the particular insult of that.
I had already tried the usual advice. A purple shampoo made for people, which turned his coat to straw inside a week. A generic whitening wash that smelled like dish soap and left him flat and dull. More cold water and more elbow grease, which mostly made both of us cross. What I wanted was something that lifted the yellow without pulling the last of the oil out of his skin, because a gray Arabian in Arizona sun does not need one more thing drying him out. The 32 ounce bottle of Cowboy Magic Yellowout was the fourth thing I tried that spring. It is the only one still sitting on the shelf in my tack room.
The Quick Verdict
The best whitening shampoo I have put on a gray in 25 years, with one honest caveat: it lifts yellow, it does not lift ground-in grass or old manure, and you still have to do the work.
Amazon Check Today's Price →The bottle that took the yellow off a gray Arabian without taking the oil out of his coat
Cowboy Magic Yellowout, 32 ounces of gel shampoo with aloe vera and chamomile, made to brighten every coat color and rinse out clean. It is the one I keep buying.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →How I've Used It
My setup is a four-stall shed-row barn with a concrete wash rack at one end, and from April through October that rack earns its keep. I washed Sahir with Cowboy Magic Yellowout about every other week during show season and once a month through the winter, always after a ride so the worst of the dust had already come off with the brush. I wet him down, worked the gel into the stained areas first, the barrel, the hips, the backs of the hind legs and the roots of the tail, then let it sit while I did his mane. Then I rinsed, and rinsed again, because I have been burned before by shampoos that leave a film that shows up two days later as dull patches.
Two things showed up in the first month. It rinses out faster than anything else I have used, which matters when it is 104 degrees and the horse has decided he is done standing. And the aloe vera and chamomile on the label is not just decoration. His skin, which goes flaky under most shampoos, stayed soft through the whole season. On a horse who wears a blanket eight months out of the year, that counts for more than the whitening. The scent is mild and it does not hang around afterward, which I consider a plus. I do not want my saddle pad smelling like a candle shop.
I used it on Nadia, my 9-year-old bay mare, and on Kasim, the 22-year-old chestnut gelding who is retired and spends most of his day in the shade. Neither one is gray, so I was not expecting much past clean. What I got was shine, the real kind, particularly on Kasim, whose coat had gone flat with age and a lot of standing around. There was no color change on either of them and I would be lying if I said otherwise. The label says it brightens coats of all colors, and I believe that, but on a bay it behaves like a shine shampoo and not a whitening one.
What the Formula Actually Does
Nothing on the label promises to bleach anything, and I appreciate that. The claim is that it brightens and helps neutralize yellow tones, and after six months I would say that is accurate and no more than accurate. It is a gel shampoo, which I like because it stays where you put it instead of running off the shoulder before you can work it in. The aloe vera and chamomile are there to put moisture back, and the formula is built to rinse out without leaving residue or buildup. That combination is what makes it work on a gray. It lifts the dirt and the dullness without stripping the coat down to nothing.
Here is the thing about gray horses that nobody tells you when you buy one. A gray coat is not white. It is white hair mixed with dark hair, and it holds dust and body oil in a way a bay never does. The yellow you see on a gray in summer is mostly dried sweat, dust, and sun, sitting in hair that has been washed too hard and has given up. A harsh shampoo makes that worse, because it strips the coat and the coat answers by producing more oil. A gentler one that still lifts the dirt gets you further over a season than a strong one that gets you cleaner for three days.
I am not going to pretend I understand the chemistry. What I can tell you is what I watched. Sahir's coat did not go chalk white in one wash and I would not trust a product that promised it. It went from yellow-gray to a clean, cool gray over about three washes, and it stayed there as long as I kept up with it. That is the whole pitch, honestly. It is not an eraser. It is a shampoo that does its job and then gets out of the way, which is more than I can say for the last four I tried.
Six Months of Results, Horse by Horse
The first wash was the one I doubted. I lathered him up, let it sit, rinsed, and put him under the fan to dry. When he dried he was cleaner, but there was still a shadow of yellow along the barrel. The second wash, two weeks later, took that out. By the third, in mid-April, he looked like a different horse in the crossties. I showed him at the regional open show in May and had two people ask what I was feeding him. I was not feeding him anything different. I was washing him with Cowboy Magic Yellowout every other week and brushing him twice a day.
The durability surprised me more than the color. In June we got a monsoon dust storm that turned the whole place orange and left a film on everything with a flat surface, horses included. I washed him three days later and the yellow came off in one pass, where in past years it would have taken two or three washes and a lot of cursing. Twenty days after that bath, with two rides a day and no cover, his barrel was still gray-white instead of the pale yellow it used to go by day ten.
Kasim is the one who convinced me it was not just about color. He is 22, his coat has thinned with age, and I have to be careful what I put on him because his skin is sensitive. Two washes with this and his coat had a sheen I had not seen on him in three years. Nadia, who is thin-skinned and reacts to everything, had no hives, no flaking, no rubbing. That is not a small thing in a desert barn where a reaction means a vet call and a week of watching. I would keep buying it for that alone, before I even got to the whitening.
Twenty days after a bath, with two rides a day and no cover, Sahir's barrel was still gray-white instead of the pale yellow it used to go by day ten.
Where It Falls Short
It does not touch ground-in grass stain. Sahir gets a green smudge on the backs of his hind cannons every spring from the irrigated pasture, and this shampoo lightened it and did not remove it. Neither did anything else I have tried, so I am not holding it against the product, but I want you to know before you buy. Same with manure stains that have baked in for a week. Wash them early or you will be disappointed. It also does nothing for sun bleaching, which is a change in the pigment of the hair itself, not a stain sitting on top of it. No shampoo fixes that. Only shade and time do.
The other thing is the work. This is not a spray-and-go product. You have to wet the horse, work it in, let it sit, and rinse thoroughly, and on a full-sized horse that is twenty minutes of your afternoon. I do not mind it because I am out there anyway, but if you are looking for something to wipe on before a show, this is the wrong tool. A gel also does not lather as dramatically as a liquid, which took me a wash to get used to. That is cosmetic, but it is worth mentioning so you do not think you got a bad bottle.
What I Tried Before This
Before this bottle I spent two years cycling through whitening shampoos. There was a blue one that worked well for a single wash and then seemed to build up on the coat until he looked dingy again. There was a powder you mix with water that smelled strongly and left him itchy for two days. There was the human purple shampoo, which is the worst thing I have ever done to a horse's coat, and I include the time I clipped a bridle path with a dull blade. Each of them solved the yellow for about a week and cost me something else, either moisture, or shine, or his patience.
What Cowboy Magic Yellowout did differently was not strip him. I think that is the whole difference. The other shampoos were trying to win a fight with the stain and the coat was collateral damage. This one lifts the dirt, puts a little moisture back with the aloe vera and chamomile, and rinses out clean so nothing sits on the hair all week. Over a season that adds up to a coat that looks better in July than it did in April, which has never happened here before. That is a low bar and it cleared it anyway.
What I Liked
- Lifts yellow out of a gray coat over two or three washes, and it holds between baths
- Rinses out fast with no leftover film or buildup
- Aloe vera and chamomile left my sensitive mare's skin soft, with no hives and no flaking
- Puts real shine on bays and chestnuts even though it does not change their color
- Mild scent that does not linger on the horse or the saddle pad
- The 32 ounce bottle lasted most of a show season across three horses
Where It Falls Short
- Does not remove ground-in grass stain or manure that has baked in
- Does nothing at all for sun bleaching
- The gel does not lather much, which takes a wash or two to get used to
- Needs a full wet, work, sit, rinse routine, about twenty minutes a horse
Who This Is For
This is for the person with a gray, a white, a palomino, or a roan that has to look decent in public. It is for anyone who has watched a light-colored coat go yellow in the summer and tried everything on the shelf without finding the one that does not dry the horse out. It is also for anyone with a sensitive-skinned horse, because after six months on three very different horses, this is the only shampoo in my barn that never once caused a reaction. If you show, if you take photographs, or if you just want your gray to look like a gray and not a dirty sock, this is the bottle I would hand you.
Who Should Skip It
If your problem is sun bleaching rather than dirt, skip it. No shampoo changes the color of a hair that has been bleached by the Arizona sun, and you will spend the money and be disappointed. If you want something you can spray on and walk away from, this is not that either. And if your horse has a genuinely stubborn stain problem, the kind that comes from standing in mud or from a wound that has drained, call your vet first and do not expect a grooming product to solve it. Thorough rinsing is part of how this works, so if you are the type to hose and go, it will not do much for you.
Six months, three Arabians, one bottle I keep reordering
Cowboy Magic Yellowout in the 32 ounce size. It brightens every coat color, puts moisture back with aloe vera and chamomile, and rinses clean. Start with two washes two weeks apart and judge it from there, the way I did.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →